Knockemdown Crowned 2023 Thoroughbred Makeover Champion

October 14, 2023

L-R: Erin Halliwell, executive director of Thoroughbred Charities of America; Kirsten Green, executive director of the Retired Racehorse Project; Alison O’Dwyer and Knockemdown. Photo by Sarah Schaaf

The Finale Championship of the Retired Racehorse Project’s 2023 Thoroughbred Makeover and National Symposium, presented by Thoroughbred Charities of America, welcomed the five top-placed horses after two days of preliminary competition to compete for additional honors and $100,000 in prize money before an enthusiastic crowd and a worldwide audience watching via livestream. A panel of judges watched the entire day of competition and ranked the ten discipline winners to determine the overall Thoroughbred Makeover Champion, sponsored by Churchill Downs. When the points were tallied, the honor went to Knockemdown, trained by professional Alison O’Dwyer of Lake Worth, Florida.

Knockemdown is a 2019 gelding by American Pharoah out of Ancient Goddess (FR), by Iffraaj (GB), bred in Kentucky by Fifth Avenue Bloodstock. He is unraced, but posted his most recent timed work in racing training on December 27, 2021 at Turfway Park.

Knockemdown’s route to the Thoroughbred Makeover Champion title and the Carolyn Karlson Trophy took him through Dressage, scoring above 81 other entries to top the preliminary standings. Coming into the Finale on a clean slate, O’Dwyer had the opportunity to showcase more advanced maneuvers of the discipline that is often used as a foundation of training for all equestrian sports, and her decision to showcase the young Knockemdown’s introductory lateral movements and counter-canter put them to the top of the standings for the Finale round as well.

Alison O’Dwyer and Knockemdown during the Finale. Photo by Sarah Schaaf

“I want to thank Kristen Goncharoff at e5 Racing Thoroughbreds for making the phone call, and Bob [Edwards], the leader of e5, who was looking to rehome this horse,” says O’Dwyer. “Wesley Ward had him in training at Turfway and when he didn’t think much of him, they decided to cut his career short as a two-year-old. I’m thankful for the friendships that I’ve made that trusted me with this horse – Kristen loved this horse as a foal and there was something about his personality and his eye that really spoke to her.”

O’Dwyer admits that she wasn’t quite as smitten with Knockemdown on initial appearance, as she typically takes bigger, flashier horses in for resale, and Knockemdown is a 15.2 bay with no markings – but once she took her first ride on the young horse, her opinion changed. “It felt like putting a shoe that’s the perfect size,” she describes. “It was a Cinderella moment from the first ride. He’s the right size for me, he’s the right brain – he’s the right everything. It is extra special that he is appreciated here as much as I appreciate him myself.”

L-R: Gina Gans and Arklow; Kirsten Green, executive director of the Retired Racehorse Project; Erin Halliwell, executive director of Thoroughbred Charities of America. Photo by Sarah Schaaf

The People’s Choice Award, sponsored by Achieve Equine, was determined by text-in popular vote open to both in-person and live stream attendees. This award was given to Arklow, trained by Gina Gans, the winner of Field Hunter. Arklow (Arch – Unbridled Empire, by Empire Maker) is a 2014 gelding bred in Kentucky by John R. Penn and Frank Penn; he sold as a yearling for $160,000 at Keeneland September consigned by Penn Sales. He raced for Donegal Racing and Joseph Bulger in a remarkable career that spanned seven seasons, racking up multiple graded stakes wins, three attempts at the Breeders’ Cup Turf, and over $3 million in earnings. He won the Field Hunter discipline in both preliminary and Finale rounds.

Thoroughbred Makeover Finale Discipline Winners (in order of go):

Eventing, sponsored by Phoenix Performance Products: Smokeonthehorizon and Jhett Jenkins (professional)
Show Jumper, sponsored by Excel Equine: Limonata and Claudia Dollinger (professional)
Show Hunter, sponsored by Beyond the Wire: Mission Canyon and Chris Bennings
Field Hunter, sponsored by Masters of Foxhounds Association: Arklow and Gina Gans (amateur)
Dressage, sponsored by PTHA’s Turning For Home: Knockemdown and Alison O’Dwyer (professional)
Polo, sponsored by United States Polo Association: Phlox and Buck Schott (professional)
Freestyle, sponsored by New Start: Burl and Hamby’s Rockin H Ranch (team)
Barrel Racing, sponsored by SmartPak: Balboas Smile and Kaitlyn Aitken (professional)
Competitive Trail, sponsored by Godolphin: Adios Dee Dee and Haley Castleberry (amateur)
Ranch Work, sponsored by Triple Crown Feeds: Into Magarayquaza and Amber Jacobson (professional)

Find full results at TheRRP.org/makeover-results.

In Other News

January 30, 2025

James & Shari Ough Donate $25,000 to Increase Prize Money at Thoroughbred Makeover

This additional prize money will offer payout through tenth place for the new Championship format that debuts this year.…
Read More
Featured image for “James & Shari Ough Donate $25,000 to Increase Prize Money at Thoroughbred Makeover”
January 27, 2025

DNF: What Is It, Why Does It Happen, and What Does It Mean for Thoroughbreds?

There are many reasons a Thoroughbred might not finish a race. Read on to learn about the possible causes and how the horse can make a successful return to racing.…
Read More
Featured image for “DNF: What Is It, Why Does It Happen, and What Does It Mean for Thoroughbreds?”
January 21, 2025

Tally Ho: Ex-Racehorses Can Find Homes in the Hunt Field

Mid-Atlantic Thoroughbred…
Read More
Featured image for “Tally Ho: Ex-Racehorses Can Find Homes in the Hunt Field”
January 20, 2025

Makeover Participants and the Racing Industry Survey

No excerpt…
Read More
January 17, 2025

RRP’s Aftercare Industry Month Virtual Conference Returns for 2025

Four webinar sessions featuring panelists from both non-profit organizations as well as business entities will delve into a range of topics that pertain to everyone who works in Thoroughbred aftercare.…
Read More
Featured image for “RRP’s Aftercare Industry Month Virtual Conference Returns for 2025”
January 15, 2025

Retired Racehorse Project Elects New Board Members

Welcome, Chris Knehr and Robert Hartman!…
Read More
Featured image for “Retired Racehorse Project Elects New Board Members”
January 13, 2025

2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Reconditioning the Broodmare

Featuring Larkspur Carroll, founder and owner of CORE Therapies, and Natanya Nieman, DVM, General Manager and Resident Veterinarian of WinStar Farm.…
Read More
Featured image for “2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Reconditioning the Broodmare”
January 13, 2025

2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Nutrition for Transitioning Broodmares

Featuring Catherine Whitehouse, Nutritionist at Kentucky Equine Research.…
Read More
Featured image for “2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Nutrition for Transitioning Broodmares”
January 13, 2025

2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Broodmare Marketing & Admin

Featuring Hillary Ramspacher, Equine Administrator and Sales Coordinator for Burleson Farm and independent rehoming agent…
Read More
Featured image for “2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Broodmare Marketing & Admin”
January 13, 2025

2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Managing Broodmare Health

Featuring Karen Wolfsdorf, DVM, SACT, Reproduction and Fertility, Hagyard Medical Institute…
Read More
Featured image for “2024 Thoroughbred Broodmare Transition Symposium: Managing Broodmare Health”
December 31, 2024

Buying & Selling Thoroughbreds Privately

People buy and sell Thoroughbred racehorses in more ways than through claiming races and at public auction. Here’s the inside scoop from racehorse trainers themselves.…
Read More
Featured image for “Buying & Selling Thoroughbreds Privately”
December 19, 2024

ASPCA Right Horse Scholarship Available for 2025 Thoroughbred Makeover

Scholarship funds are available for up to 50 eligible horses competing in the 2025 competition.…
Read More
Featured image for “ASPCA Right Horse Scholarship Available for 2025 Thoroughbred Makeover”
December 16, 2024

Ligament Injuries & How They Shape OTTB Second Careers

Ligament injuries aren’t uncommon for racehorses: take a closer look at how they occur, available treatment, and how to navigate a second career after recovery.…
Read More
Featured image for “Ligament Injuries & How They Shape OTTB Second Careers”
December 10, 2024

Ask a Trainer: First Hacks Out of the Arena

Professional Caitlan Brooks shares her tried-and-true tips for safely introducing hacks to the recently-retired racehorse.…
Read More
Featured image for “Ask a Trainer: First Hacks Out of the Arena”
December 5, 2024

2025 Thoroughbred Makeover Rulebook Now Available

Revisions to rules are indicated in red and clarifications are indicated in blue.…
Read More
Featured image for “2025 Thoroughbred Makeover Rulebook Now Available”
December 1, 2024

Second Acts: Champions For the Breed

BloodHorse…
Read More
Featured image for “Second Acts: Champions For the Breed”
November 26, 2024

To Pass or To Fail: That Used to Be the Question

Whether a horse “passes” or “fails” a pre-purchase exam (PPE) is an outdated interpretation: how can a PPE help a buyer?…
Read More
Featured image for “To Pass or To Fail: That Used to Be the Question”
November 25, 2024

RRP Announces $38,700 Match for 2024 Year-End Giving Campaign

The RRP announces the launch of its 2024 year-end giving campaign with a total goal of $100,000, including a $38,700 match pledge that will double contributions from donors who support the organization’s charitable mission to increase demand for Thoroughbreds beyond…
Read More
Featured image for “RRP Announces $38,700 Match for 2024 Year-End Giving Campaign”
November 1, 2024

The Cost of Aftercare

Mid-Atlantic Thoroughbred…
Read More
Featured image for “The Cost of Aftercare”
October 28, 2024

Feeding the Racing Thoroughbred

Understanding the diet of the racing Thoroughbred can help inform a smoother transition to a career beyond racing.…
Read More
Featured image for “Feeding the Racing Thoroughbred”
October 15, 2024

Retired Racehorse Project’s 2024 Thoroughbred Makeover Showcases the Breed Beyond Racing

The 2024 Thoroughbred Makeover was the ninth edition of the event in Kentucky.…
Read More
Featured image for “Retired Racehorse Project’s 2024 Thoroughbred Makeover Showcases the Breed Beyond Racing”
October 14, 2024

Picking Prospects Fall 2024

Makeover trainers evaluate sport horse potential based on conformation shots.…
Read More
Featured image for “Picking Prospects Fall 2024”
October 12, 2024

Big Fame Is Named 2024 Thoroughbred Makeover Champion, Sponsored by Churchill Downs Inc.

The top title went to Big Fame, trained by Angela Carmitchel.…
Read More
Featured image for “Big Fame Is Named 2024 Thoroughbred Makeover Champion, Sponsored by Churchill Downs Inc.”
October 10, 2024

Preliminary Competition Concludes at the 2024 Thoroughbred Makeover

That’s a wrap on preliminary days at North America’s largest retraining competition for Thoroughbreds!…
Read More
Featured image for “Preliminary Competition Concludes at the 2024 Thoroughbred Makeover”